I.B.O.A House Stephen Street Upper Dublin 2







May 2008

Crazy Hand
Crazy Result

Polish open Trials 2008
This crazy hand from the Polish open trials produced a big
swing to one side

Closed Room

West
North
East
South
Martens
Zawislak
Jassem
Pazur
2C
2H
Pass
3H
Dbl
Rdbl
Pass
3NT
All Pass


The bidding was a bit strange in the closed room
2C Showed at least 5/4 in the majors and less than opening values
I have no idea what 2H was but it must have shown minors. West bid 3H (again no idea what it meant) and the final contract of 3NT was reached.
Unfortunately for North he chose the wrong major to lead when he chose a small heart which declarer let run to his Queen.
Dummy was entered with a club to the King to run the Queen of Diamonds,Diamonds were continued then the Jack of clubs to the Ace and Ace of Hearts brought his total to nine tricks
No doubt West may have thought it was a good board for his side but it was not to be

Open Room

West
North
East
South
Kwiecien
Gierulski
Jagniewski
Skrzypczak
1S
2NT
3C
5D
5S
Pass
Pass
6C
6S
Pass
Pass
7D
Dbl
All Pass

The bidding and stakes were much higher in the Open Room
North felt his hand was worth an opening bid and so opened 1S
East bid a normal 2NT to show both minors, and now West refused to be outbid going all the way to 7D which was doubled by North.
Again North led a small Heart which declarer ran to his Queen
A spade was ruffed high, and a high Diamond was lead and ran when South played low, trumps were drawn.
Now a club to the King and the Jack of clubs led and ran picked up that suit also to land his doubled grand slam.
+ 1630 for a very well bid and played hand
and 15 IMPS for his side

April 2008

Multi two Diamonds,
Strikes again

Vanderbilt Quarter-Final 2008



Closed Room

West
North
East
South
Jaggy
Sontag
Allegaert
Bates
Pass
1D
Pass
1S
Pass
1NT
2D
2S
All Pass


In the closed room the quiet auction above led to a normal contract of two spades by North which made nine tricks +140

Open Room

West
North
East
South
Helgemo
Bathurst
Helness
J Lall
2D
Dbl
Pass
3H
Pass
3NT
Pass
4H
All Pass

When top players in the world, playing in one of the worlds top tournaments have a major bidding misunderstanding the rest of us mere mortals tend to smile and take comfort.
This hand from the Vanderbilt Quarterfinal 2008
was one such hand


When Tor Helness opened this hand with a Multi 2 Diamond he surely never expected what happened next
North bid 3 Hearts which was meant as a transfer response (showing spades) but South responded 3nt, North again tried to transfer to spades by bidding 4 hearts, but south passed and their they played in their 2 - 2 fit
The contract finished seven down
-700 and 15 IMPS away


March 2008

Spades, Diamonds, Clubs
or No Trumps

This hand from the British open trials was interesting.
What contract would you play this hand in if playing with your favourite partner


Looking at all four hands you can see that 6NT is unbeatable if played by East however neither room found their way there

Open Room

West
North
East
South
Armstrong
McIntosh
Holland
Hallberg
1C
Pass
1S
Pass
1NT
Pass
2C
Pass
2D
Pass
3D
Pass
3NT
Pass
4S
All Pass

In the Open room East West, Armstrong Holland bid as shown to 4 spades which made 11 tricks after a diamond lead


Closed Room

West
North
East
South
Townsend
Hackett
Gold
Waterlow
1C
Pass
1H (1)
Pass
2D
Pass
3D
Pass
3NT
Pass
4D
Pass
4H
Pass
4NT
Pass
5D
All Pass
     

The auction in the closed room was a little different. The 1 heart response by Townsend showed spades, they found their diamond fit investigated slam and then settled for game when two key cards were missing.
South lead the Ace of hearts then switched to a spade.
Gold won in hand and had to decide how to tackle the trump suit

In the end he played a diamond to the ace and a diamond to the Queen, unfortunately it was not his day and the contract was down one and 13 IMPS away

Feb 2008

How is your
declarer play

This hand found declarer wanting, however their was a 100% line available and all good declarers should make this slam
Are you up to the task



The contract is six Hearts and west lead a trump

Declarer has eleven top tricks 6 Hearts 2 spades 2 Diamonds and a club and a winning finesse in any suit will bring his total to 12

Declarer played two rounds of trumps and not wanting to take the wrong finesse played the king and ace of spades and ruffed a spade hoping to bring down the queen in three rounds no luck. he then turned his attention to diamonds and finessed the jack again no luck and finally tried the club finesse and when this failed claimed he was very unlucky
It is true he was unlucky to find west with all the missing cards but his partner was quick to point out that their was a 100% line available
After drawing trumps play the King and another spade and cover whatever spade East plays.
If West wins he is endplayed in three suits and any return hands South his slam.
Even after playing three rounds of spades south could have recovered by coming to hand with a trump and leading the 10 of spades and discarding in dummy.
West wins but is again endplayed and forced to lead a minor suit solving all declarers problems

Jan 2008

More high level judgement
Cayne v Garozzo
Internet match 2007

This hand from an internet match produced a a swing of 16 IMPS how would you have fared in the west seat

Open Room

West
North
East
South
Fantoni
Weed
Nunes
Stewart
1S
4H
4S
5H
5S
Pass
Pass
Dbl
All Pass

In the Open room East West, the world famous pair Italian pair of Fulvio Fantoni and Claudio Nunes bid on over five hearts, were doubled and went for 800


Closed Room

West
North
East
South
Reisig
Simpson
Garozzo
Cayne
1S
4H
4S
5H
Dbl
All Pass

In the Closed room USA WGM Richard Reisig chose to double
in the West seat and picked up +500 for his side when the contract
went down two
800 plus 500 =
a gain of 16 IMPS

Dec 2007

How is your high level judgement
English Open Trials 2007

This hand from the English open trials produced a swing of 15 IMPS how would you have fared

Open Room

West
North
East
South
Robson
Armstrong
Allfrey
Holland
Pass
1H
1H
4S
All Pass

In the Open room East West were allowed play in four spades
North lead a heart to the King and Ace
South did not find the club switch but instead continued hearts ,so declarer's Diamond loser disappeared on the Heart Queen
South was on lead again with the King of spades but again failed to find the club switch this time leading the Ace of Diamonds, declarer ruffed drew trumps and claimed 10 tricks + 420

The Closed room saw N/S bid on to the five level and were doubled

Closed Room

West
North
East
South
Hackett
Forrester
Waterlow
Bakhshi
Pass
1NT
2H
4S
5H
DBL
All Pass

West lead a Diamond which caused declarer no problems
He won with the Queen ruffed a club played a spade to his King
ruffed another club, cashed the Ace of spades discarding his losing Diamond and ruffed a spade to hand
It made no difference what East played (he actually discarded a club)
Declarer now ruffed his last club in dummy and claimed 11 tricks +850
to add to the 420 in the other room for a gain of 15 IMPS

Nov 2007

Find the lead
Naturalists v Scientists 2007

This hand from a match of two top class teams one using natural bidding system and the other using scientific methods proved a big winner for the naturalists

Closed Room

West
North
East
South
Hallberg
Dmitri
Brogeland
Hargreave
1D
P
1H
1NT
2D
3C
3H
3NT
4C
P
4H
All Pass

In the closed room East West for the naturalists ended in 4H doubled on the auction shown, and after an unfortunate Ace of club lead by North ruffed by declarer he simply discarded his spade loser on the Ace of diamonds and ruffed his other club loser in dummy before drawing trumps and claiming 12 tricks and plus 1190 for his side

The open room saw a different auction

Open Room

West
North
East
South
Motley
Robson
Wolfson
Zia
1D
P
3H
3NT
4H
5C
5H
6C
P
Pass
6H
Dbl
All Pass

This time Zia and Robson for the Naturalists bid on over 4H and again over 5H and doubled the final contract of six hearts
This time there was no accident on the lead as Robson lead Ace and another trump
to ensure a two trick defeat for the slam and another 500 points to add to the 1190 in the other room for a gain of 17 IMPS

Oct 2007

Zia magic
Bermuda Bowl 2007

USA1 V USA2

This hand from the 2007 Bermuda Bowl saw Zia Mahmood bid and make a slam which was not bid by other top teams in the competition


Open Room

West
North
East
South
Rodwell
Garner
Meckstroth
Weinstein
3S
DBL
4S
5D
All Pass

In the open room East West ended in 5D on the auction shown and made exactly eleven tricks

Things were a bit different however in the closed room

Closed Room

West
North
East
South
Zia
Hamman
Rosenberg
Lall
2S
DBL
3S
dbl
Pass
5C
Pass
5D
Pass
5H
Pass
6D
All Pass

This time Bob Hamman only bid 2S with the North hand and the auction proceeded as shown
North lead a spade which Zia won in dummy and found the brilliant play of a small heart to the 9 at trick 2
Slam made

Elsewhere in New Zealand v Brazil
New Zealand played in 5D+1 Brazil 3NT+1
China v Argentina
China played in 5D while Argentina played in 3D+3

Sept 2007

Netherlands v Denmark
2007

This innocent looking hand from a recent match between the Netherlands and Denmark produced a 14 IMP swing to the Netherlands despite Denmark bidding and making a game in one room


Open Room

West
North
East
South
Pass
Pass
1H
Pass
1NT
Pass
4H
All Pass

In the open room East West had an uncontested auction to 4H which made easily for eleven tricks

Things were a bit different however in the closed room

Closed Room

West
North
East
South
Pass
Pass
1H
Pass
1NT
DBL
Rdbl
All Pass

This time South passed as dealer but doubled on the second round and stood the redouble when it came back
North lead the jack of hearts which did not cause declarer much trouble. Declarer won and continued hearts losing the fourth round to North who switched to diamonds, King from dummy to the Ace and South switched to a club, declarer won in hand cashed two winning hearts
South who by now must have regretted their entry into the auction had to find a lot of discards and with the king of spades right for declarer ended up with 11 tricks for +1360 and fourteen IMPS

Aug 2007

Just another "push" board
Springold Semi Final
Nickell v Henner-Welland 2007

This hand from the Semi Final of this years Springold
saw one of the most remarkable auctions repeater at both tables

Open Room

West
North
East
South
Wrang
Meckstroth
Nisson
Rodwell
Pass
1S
2H
4S
5C (1)
All Pass

1 Lead directing

Wrang in the west seat bid 5C as a lead directing bid against a possible 5S, however his partner was not on the same wavelenght and decided to pass
When 5C came around to Rodwell he obviously knew there had been an accident in the bidding but could not be sure that 5S could make so decided to take the certain plus in 5C
This contract drifted off 6 tricks for +300 to North South and we sat back and waited for the action in the closed room

Closed Room

West
North
East
South
Nickell
Sementa
Lall
Henner
Pass
1S
2H
2NT
4H
4S
Pass
Pass
5C (1)
Pass
Pass
Dbl
5H
Pass
Pass
Dbl
All Pass
     

Again North- South arrived in 4S and again west bid 5C as a lead directing bid against 5S and again remarkably east passed.
This time however south doubled and Nickell lost no time in running to 5H which again south doubled.
This contract drifted 2 off also for +300 to north-south and a remarkable flat board

July 2007